NYC comptroller exposes expensive testing and vaccination program mismanagement

Loading Video…

This browser does not support the Video element.

NYC comptroller blasts health department for pandemic costs

A report claims the Health Department often overpaid for both vaccines and tests. FOX 5 NY's Morgan McKay has more.

New York City Comptroller Brad Lander in a new audit found that a company hired by the city to administer COVID tests and vaccines was able to make millions due to a lack of oversight. 

"They just did not do good planning," Comptroller Lander said.

As a result, depending on the location, each test administered cost taxpayers between $202 and $937.

This varied even more for vaccinations, with each shot costing taxpayers between $169 and $2,423.

In the height of the COVID pandemic, the city contracted with a company called Executive Medical Services to set up testing sites around the city.

The Health Department would be billed: $150 for every worker per hour, $100 for each test administered, and then later $25 for each vaccine shot dispensed.

'Long COVID is a real condition,' doctors insist after study

The long COVID study is ongoing as research found that nearly ten thousand Americans experienced symptoms.

But the city never placed a cap on how many workers this company could hire which meant that the less busy a location, the more expensive the test or vaccine.

A spokesperson for the City Health Department said there are complexities to running these sites and in some locations, they were worried wait times would deter people from getting a test or vaccine.

They continued, "The COVID-19 response was the largest and most successful vaccination campaign in the city’s history, and it resulted in 99 percent of adult New Yorkers receiving at least one dose. The coordination between agencies, staff, and administrations reflected an unprecedented whole-of-government approach that employed resources across jurisdictions to get services and supports to people who needed them most."

Billions of dollars in COVID-19 relief aid stolen or wasted, investigation reveals

The investigation uncovers a pattern of fraudulent activities, embezzlement, and mismanagement of funds that have plagued COVID-19 relief efforts worldwide.

Lander says even in an emergency there still needs to be some sort of oversight of city contracts and competitive pricing.

Pointing to this latest contract, Lander says the city should have required the vendor to spread out resources.

In the scope of about three years, the city paid Executive Medical Services around $390 million for their services.